No figure in American history has evoked such an extraordinarily wide range of praise and blame, and condemnation and deification, as John Brown. Zoe Trodd and John Stauffer's marvelous anthology helps us understand how a supposed madman and brutal terrorist could also be hailed as a saint or as an anti-racist Jesus who turned the gallows into a cross
--David Brion Davis
In their brilliant introduction, Trodd and Stauffer elucidate with precision the still living legend of John Brown, liberator of the slaves. In complex and dramatic ways, Brown remains a mythic figure demonstrating both the structural violence and the potential redemption of American society. Their much needed and judicious selection of letters and other primary documents shows Brown playing out his dramatic life, often in confusion, anger, and defeat, but finally, in imitation of St. Paul and Christ, transforming himself into the American martyr incarnate. As other documents reveal, Brown’s contemporaries immediately reacted to what could be made of the life and death personal and political meanings that revealed the depth of contradiction between liberty and slavery, the paramount American aspiration and the great American evil
--Michael Fellman
Trodd and Stauffer have compiled an impressive collection of documents, including many of Brown's personal letters and writings, letters of his contemporaries, newspaper articles, testimonies, reminiscences, and oratorical classics. Meteor of War also includes over 30 images, a scholarly bibliography, and a very helpful chronology that traces John Brown's life in parallel with the major events of the antebellum US, all of which give this labor an added value for classroom use. Equally notable is the well-written introduction in which Brown's historical and cultural image is considered. Stauffer and Trodd are literary scholars, and their opening commentary provides a fascinating interpretation of the Old Man as a mythic figure.... Broadly researched and well-written
--Louis A. DeCaro Jr.
A brilliant collection of annotated primary sources
--Steven Mintz
--David Brion Davis
In their brilliant introduction, Trodd and Stauffer elucidate with precision the still living legend of John Brown, liberator of the slaves. In complex and dramatic ways, Brown remains a mythic figure demonstrating both the structural violence and the potential redemption of American society. Their much needed and judicious selection of letters and other primary documents shows Brown playing out his dramatic life, often in confusion, anger, and defeat, but finally, in imitation of St. Paul and Christ, transforming himself into the American martyr incarnate. As other documents reveal, Brown’s contemporaries immediately reacted to what could be made of the life and death personal and political meanings that revealed the depth of contradiction between liberty and slavery, the paramount American aspiration and the great American evil
--Michael Fellman
Trodd and Stauffer have compiled an impressive collection of documents, including many of Brown's personal letters and writings, letters of his contemporaries, newspaper articles, testimonies, reminiscences, and oratorical classics. Meteor of War also includes over 30 images, a scholarly bibliography, and a very helpful chronology that traces John Brown's life in parallel with the major events of the antebellum US, all of which give this labor an added value for classroom use. Equally notable is the well-written introduction in which Brown's historical and cultural image is considered. Stauffer and Trodd are literary scholars, and their opening commentary provides a fascinating interpretation of the Old Man as a mythic figure.... Broadly researched and well-written
--Louis A. DeCaro Jr.
A brilliant collection of annotated primary sources
--Steven Mintz
